Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Reasoning together or against each other? Learning outcomes of deliberative versus disputative argumentation.

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

Abstract

Theoretical and empirical work suggests that deliberative argumentation—dialogue characterized by joint and issue-driven reasoning and critique—is more conducive to conceptual learning than disputative argumentation, which emphasizes interpersonal competition during disagreement. However, experimental evidence that isolates the effect of these differences in rhetorical style from other dialogue features remains limited. We report on two randomized controlled experiments that examined how deliberative versus disputative argumentation influences conceptual understanding of natural selection. In Study 1, undergraduate students (N = 58) learned about natural selection and then engaged in chat-based argumentation with a disagreeing confederate on their solutions to transfer tasks. The confederate's verbal behavior was scripted to evoke critical discourse on the explanations, while controlling for content, length, arguments, and types of dialogue moves, but differing in rhetorical style (disputative/deliberative). In Study 2, a new sample (N = 88) read either a deliberative or a disputative dialogue between two peers. Across both studies, deliberative argumentation resulted in greater conceptual understanding than disputative argumentation, after controlling for pretest differences. Moreover, rhetorical style affected participants’ sociocognitive perceptions: Those exposed to deliberative argumentation rated their partner and the dialogue more positively and showed greater willingness to revise their initial explanations and collaborate again. Taken together, these findings provide robust experimental evidence that rhetorical style plays a pivotal role in argumentation for conceptual learning.

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Educational Psychology
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - 2026

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2026 The Author(s) This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0; https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0). This license permits copying and redistributing the work in any medium or format for noncommercial use provided the original authors and source are credited and a link to the license is included in attribution. No derivative works are permitted under this license. All rights, including for text and data mining, AI training, and similar technologies, are reserved.

Keywords

  • argumentation
  • conceptual learning
  • deliberation
  • discourse style
  • sociocognitive processes

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Reasoning together or against each other? Learning outcomes of deliberative versus disputative argumentation.'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this